Tolerances
What general tolerances are required for sand castings?
A general tolerance of +/-.030" is obtainable on sand castings up to 12" in length.
For castings larger than 12" the tolerance should be increased an additional +/-.002"
per inch.
Wherever a casting design permits, allowing a greater tolerance (even if only
on specific dimensions) will result in a more economical design.
Surfaces that will be machined should be allowed double the suggested
tolerance in the plus direction.
For example: a casting with a general tolerance of +/-.030 should have a
tolerance of +.060/-.030 on surfaces that will be machined.
This will minimize the work required in finishing the casting.
Castings in solution heat treated alloys such as 356.0-T6 that are relatively thin
are subject to distortion during the heat treat solution and quenching cycles. A
straightening operation is then required to remove this distortion. Increasing
tolerances in noncritical areas will reduce the time required to straighten the
casting.
What if closer tolerances are needed?
It is possible to hold tolerances as close as one half of those described above
on certain features. This is possible by controlling tool design, molding methods
and secondary finishing operations. However, you should consult with our foundry
engineering staff before finalizing your design.
What about the added weight due to increased tolerances?
Increasing tolerances can potentially increase the weight of a dimensionally
acceptable casting. However, if weight is critical, a better way of controlling
it is to specify a maximum weight. This is best accomplished by calculating
a maximum design weight and then refining it, if necessary, during
initial casting production. Controlling weight in this manner allows
the foundry greater flexibility and results in a more economical casting.
Draft
How much draft is required?
A draft angle of one degree is adequate for vertical surfaces between 1
and 4 inches in height. For surfaces under 1" in height, .010" to .015" is
required regardless of height. For surfaces over 4" in height, .060" every
8" to 10" is required.
How should draft be shown on a drawing?
Draft should not be shown in the field of the drawing but should be
specified in a drawing note such as "Draft angle: 1 degree max.". This
will allow the foundry to use minimum draft where required, up to a
maximum of 1 degree, on those surfaces that are vertical to the mold
parting line or, in the case of cores, vertical to the line of draw.
On those surfaces under 1" in height the draft will actually exceed 1
degree but this excess will be within the general drawing tolerances
and is not considered a violation of the general draft note.
What if draft will interfere with the casting function?
If a draft angle of 1 degree on certain surfaces will interfere
with casting function you should identify these surfaces on the drawing
and specify how much draft, if any, may be allowed.
Wall Thickness
How thin a wall can be cast?
The thinnest nominal wall that can economically be cast depends on
several factors:
Total area of the wall;
Orientation of the wall in the mold;
Alloy to be cast;
Distance of the wall from the gating system; and
Casting soundness and strength requirements.
The 300 and 400 series alloys containing silicon are the most fluid of the aluminum
alloys. The following comments apply to these alloys:
Nominal walls of .12" can be cast up to 3" in height and 50 square
inches in area. For each additional 1.5" in height or 50 square inches in area the
nominal wall thickness should be increased .03".
For other alloy series the thinnest nominal wall thickness will have to
be increased 25% to 40% above these values. Consult with our foundry
engineering staff when using these alloys.
Producing localized thin walls in castings that are predominantly thick
walled can often create problems for the foundry, especially when the
casting soundness and strength requirements are high. Consult with Rainier
Cast Parts foundry in these instances.
Surface Finish
What is the normal sand cast surface finish?
Surface finish on castings is affected by several factors:
Molding methods and materials;
Weight and surface area of the casting;
Finishing methods;
Wall thickness; and
Casting soundness and strength requirements.
Generally a 250 rms finish is typical for sand castings. It is
important to note that the surface finish of a sand casting
should be determined by visual and tactile comparison to a
standard such as the Aluminum Association's AA-CS-E18 Cast
Surface Comparator and not measured with a machine designed to
measure a more uniform machined surface.
Machine Stock
How much machine stock is necessary?
Machine stock requirements vary with casting size:
Up to 10" in length allow .09" per surface;
Over 10" and up to 25" in length allow .13" per surface;
Over 25" and up to 40" in length allow .16" per surface;
Over 40" and up to 55" in length allow .19" per surface.
For larger castings over 55" in length consult the foundry.
Casting Drawings
Is a casting drawing necessary?
Obviously some sort of drawing, either a hard copy or CAD file, is
necessary to describe the part geometry. However, a casting drawing
describing only the casting requirements is not necessary.
A finished part drawing that describes both the casting and machining
requirements is often superior to a casting drawing. Since it defines the extent of
machining the foundry can take this into consideration when specifying
the tooling, gating system and foundry processes. This allows the
foundry to restrict, where possible, gating contact points to surfaces
that will be machined. Also, casting requirements such as surface finish
will not be applied to surfaces that will be machined away.
Porosity
What is porosity?
This is a general term referring to voids within a casting. There are three
types of porosity:
Gas Porosity:
This term refers to hydrogen gas within a casting. Molten aluminum
has such an affinity for hydrogen that it will disassociate it from other molecules
such as water and form a solution with it. As with most solutions, as the
temperature drops the hydrogen becomes less soluble and precipitates as hydrogen
gas. The greater the amount of hydrogen in the molten aluminum and the slower it
solidifies the greater the hydrogen voids will be. These voids are generally
smooth, round or slightly elongated and may be somewhat localized to the areas
of the casting that solidify last. This type of porosity is generally
undetectable visually since the surface of the casting solidifies quickest
preventing the hydrogen from forming holes large enough to be visible on the
surface except by using fluorescent penetrant inspection.
Gas Holes:
These are generally large and more localized voids than gas porosity
but they retain the smooth, round or slightly elongated shape. They are usually
caused by reaction in the mold media producing gas which bubbles through the
molten metal.
Shrinkage porosity:
This type of porosity has a rough irregular shape. It is caused by a
lack of adequate feed metal during solidification.
Can porosity be eliminated?
There will always be some porosity in aluminum castings. However, through
the use of proper foundry techniques (and sometimes slight modification of
casting geometry) it can be reduced to acceptable levels.
A key to assisting the foundry is to establish clear requirements for
porosity and to identify those areas where porosity levels are most critical.
It also helps if the foundry knows which surfaces will be machined.
How are porosity limits specified?
The most common way for aircraft and aerospace castings is by specifying
a radiographic standard such as MIL-STD-2175. This specification establishes
four grade levels for porosity and other internal defects that can be
found in castings. Each grade refers to various standard plates in ASTM E155.
Commercial castings may also use MIL-STD-2175 or other specifications such
as ASTM B26 or the Aluminum Association's AA-CS-M Series. These specifications
also establish grade levels referring to ASTM E155.
All of the specifications listed above provide for various levels of
inspection from foundry control (radiographic inspection of initial sample
casting(s) only) to production sample plans (radiographic inspection of samples
taken from each lot of castings) and 100% inspection of every casting.
ASTM E155 is a set of radiographic plates for classifying defect levels
in aluminum castings. Plate 1 levels are barely detectable in x-rays.
However, achieving Plate 1 levels can be quite costly. Most aircraft castings
require Plate 2 or 3 levels while commercial castings are generally at
Plate 4, 5 or 6 levels.
Can porosity levels be specified without radiography?
If the only concern is porosity exposed on the surface of the casting, limits
can be set for the maximum allowable size. However, if internal porosity is of concern,
radiography is the only practical detection method.
Casting Prices
How much will a casting cost?
Because of the many factors that determine casting prices it is impossible to
answer this question in other than general terms.
At Rainier Cast Parts our aluminum castings generally range from $4.50 to $12 per pound
and zinc castings from $2.50 to $5 per pound.
Note added 5-23-06:
I've updated the above costs. However, in the past four months
aluminum prices have increased nearly 50% and zinc 250% and it looks like they will continue
to rise in the coming months.
Copper prices are also rising but because of the great number of alloys and their
wide variation in prices, I can't give a reasonable range for pricing.
We establish casting prices on an individual basis: each casting and its requirements
is reviewed to determine tool design and manufacturing methods. From this the material,
labor and outside process requirements can be estimated and firm pricing established.
Factors that influence casting prices include:
Casting Factors:
Casting weight, size and geometry;
Tolerances;
Alloy;
Surface finish;
Soundness and strength requirements;
Machining requirements; and
Finishing requirements such as painting, etc.
Production Factors:
Total quantity required; and
Production rate.
In order for us to quote a firm price for your casting you should specify all of these
requirements in your inquiry.
|